Poly-Modding: Does it actually work?

Antec NeoHE 550W

The Original Capacitors

Unlike the CWT-made SmartPower SP-400, this unit is made by Seasonic and uses OST capacitors. They are more reliable than Fuhjyyu, but they are far from the best, and are known for failing with no visible signs of it. Like the Hipro HP-D3057F3H, this unit has two filtering capacitors for each rail. There are a 3300µF and a 1000µF capacitor on the 12V rail, a 2200µF and a 1000µF on the 5V and 3.3V rails, a 1000µF and a 330µF on the −12V rail and a 3300µF and a 220µF on the 5Vsb rail.

The replacement capacitors

Role Qty. Original Value Replacement
12V Filtering 1 3300µF 16V OST RLS 820µF 16V Nichicon LG
12V Filtering
1 1000µF 16V OST RLS
820µF 16V Nichicon LG
5V Filtering
1 2200µF 6.3V OST RLS
1500µF 6.3V Sanyo OS-CON SEPC
5V Filtering
1 1000µF 10V OST RLS
1000µF 6.3V Fujitsu RE
3.3V Filtering
1 2200µF 6.3V OST RLS
1500µF 6.3V Sanyo OS-CON SEPC
3.3V Filtering 1 1000µF 6.3V OST RLS
1000µF 6.3V Fujitsu RE
-12V Filtering
1 1000µF 16V OST RLS
820µF 16V Nichicon LG
-12V Filtering
2 220µF 16V OST RLS
330µF 16V Sanyo OS-CON SEP
5Vsb Filtering
1 3300µF 10V OST RLS
1500µF 6.3V Sanyo OS-CON SEPC
5Vsb Filtering
2 220µF 16V OST RLS
220µF 6.3V Chemi-con PSA

 

The Stress-testing

Test Result
Performance Test
Fail
24 Hour In-PC Test
N/A

 

Rail Load Voltage (After) Voltage (Before) Ripple (After) Ripple (Before)
12V 33A 11.58V 11.84V >800mV 19.0mV
5V 5A 4.91V 5.07V ? 9.4mV
3.3V 10A 3.25V 3.28V ? 7.6mV
-12V 0.1A -12.74V -12.35V ? 23.4mV
5Vsb 1A 4.91V 4.92V ? 36.2mV

 

From the moment I hit the power switch, it was obvious that this power supply wasn’t going to work well with polymer capacitors. There was an annoying high-pitched squeal, and the ripple was off the scale on the 12V rail, which means it was above 800mV. The voltage regulation was also worse. After I finished reading the voltages and 12V ripple, it shut down and wouldn’t start up again, so I didn’t get to read the ripple on the other rails. This power supply is clearly optimised for the capacitance and ESR of the original capacitors, and doesn’t work well when these properties are changed significantly.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11